Home    In The Spotlight    'V' Producers Dodge Race Question
'V' Producers Dodge Race Question 
But they should pay attention to the issue that was raised
By Blaine Kyllo | Saturday, July 25, 2009
  • Home
V, the remake of the 1980s-era miniseries about aliens coming to Earth, was the focus of a panel at Comic-Con on Saturday.

And while most of the one-hour event was taken up with a screening of the pilot episode, the most significant moment of the panel occurred when an audience member was censored from asking a relevant and thought-provoking question about race.

The new series, which has been booked by ABC as a mid-season replacement, stars Elizabeth Mitchell (Lost) as FBI agent and single mother Erica Evans. Also starring in the series are Morris Chestnut (The Cave) as businessman Ryan Nichols, Joel Gretsch (The 4400) as Catholic priest Jack Landry, Scott Wolf (Everwood) as news anchor Chad Decker and Morena Baccarin (Firefly) as Anna, head of the alien visitors that call themselves the V.

The pilot does a good job of setting up the series, and seeding the idea that the V have been on Earth for years, living as humans, and suggesting that the world's economic and political problems are as a result of the efforts of these embedded V.

In the short question and answer period that followed the screening, executive producer Scott Peters said that people seem to still be excited about the show. "A lot has happened in 25 years," he said, but world events have made the themes of the original production just as relevant today.

Elizabeth Mitchell and Morena Baccarin were also on stage with Morris Chestnut, Joel Gretsch and Scott Wolf.

Baccarin said that she watched the original mini-series with her brother. "I was totally into V. I thought it was genius."

Mitchell also watched the show. "I have huge memories of the alien baby."

The panel was nearly derailed when an audience member asked how the producers planned on addressing the "racial overtones" of the show. The question met with groans from the audience and the questioner was quickly ushered away from the microphone. The cast responded with raised eyebrows and the producers called for another question, but I hope they give the question some more thought when they get back to their offices.

Because the person who asked the question has a very valid point, even if Comic-Con may not have been the perfect place to raise the issue.

In order to explain why, though, requires that I reveal a spoiler. It's a detail that has been discussed elsewhere, so I'm not the first, but if you really want to view the pilot untainted, look away now.

Here's why the question of racial overtones when it comes to the V remake has merit.

The only significant cast member of color in the pilot was Morris Chestnut. In today's environment, where genre shows are regularly casting Asian, Hispanic and other actors of color, we can expect that proportion to be higher.

Making matters worse, it is revealed in the pilot that Chestnut's character is actually an alien disguised as a human. So from a certain perspective, the black man is an alien. That's a dangerous and loaded representation.

And to further worsen the situation, the characters who are set up in the pilot to be the heroes are played by two white actors, Elizabeth Mitchell and Joel Gretsch.

The stated plan of their characters is to resist the V, who they believe intend to destroy humanity, which is effectively a genocide. Aliens versus humans is a race war, even if the aliens are reptilian invaders.

You see how uncomfortable all this gets when you start paying attention to the representations and the overtones?

I'm certain that there was no intent by the producers and writers, but someone should have picked up on this subtext, whether it was intentional or not, especially given that the original series was a loosely-veiled metaphor for the Nazi takeover of Germany — complete with swastika-like symbology and uniforms that could have been worn by the Hitler Youth — I'd expect the producers to be more sensitive to issues of race representation in their remake.

Yes, V is a science fiction television show and not a classroom, but maybe that's even more reason for the creators to be mindful of and responsible for their representations.

Have Your Say: Commentary, debate and opinion
(11 Comments)
Color is not the issue here
Posted by Myron on March 5th, 6:44pm
It doesn't matter if the people in the show are black or white ... The show is horrible. To make matters worse the long hiatus has hurt it even more.
troubleshooter
Posted by ibsteve2U on November 3rd, 9:02pm
Black guy is an alien, the aliens talk of offering peace and hope...oh, and universal healthcare.

lolll...rather transparent, given some of the other social engineering efforts.
Racism?
Posted by Kerrie on October 21st, 11:32am
If we're not supposed to notice the color of a person's skin when considering them for jobs or parts in TV shows, then why are we supposed to notice when a person with certain color skin is there or not there? If everything is supposed to be equal regardless of the color of a person's skin, then it's just as likely to have all white people or all black people or all Asian people as it is to have a "mixed" cast or the cast that they ended up with. It also shouldn't matter whether a white or black person is the hero or villian. If you want equality, then you have to take what you get in all circumstances, and truly ignore the race issue. I don't see many white people on "The George Lopez Show" or "My Wife and Kids," but I don't see anyone complaining about that, and those shows *intentionally* used a Mexican and black cast. That is far worse than just casting a show with the best people for the roles and ending up with the cast that 'V' did.
race/color/creed/religion/planet of origin means nothing if you can't act!
Posted by Tracy on September 23rd, 10:25am
call me crazy, but myself, and most people I discuss tv shows and movies, could care less about the color of a persons skin. if they can act and make us believe they are actually that character, then give them the roles! i don't care if they cast a person who is pink with purple polka dots with one arm from jupiter,as long as i enjoy the show!!!
Unfortunate Missed Opportunity
Posted by Keith Starling on July 28th, 7:45am
I was at the panel and was shocked that the producers and cast didn't do more to quell what I view as a valid concern.

Just because talking about racial issues is uncomfortable doesn't mean they shouldn't be discussed and the quickest way to make the topic "go away" isn't to ignore it but confront it head on.

They missed a great opportunity to show how this show isn't about blond haired, blue eyed "good guys" versus various ethnic outsiders. I by no means believe that the producers had any malicious feelings or purposeful overtones about race but anything that might be taken in that light at least deserves a second look.

We shouldn't be so quick to rush people off the stage just because they ask a question that makes us uncomfortable.
The great irony
Posted by sidlerocks on July 27th, 10:44pm
I too was at the screening, and would start by pointing out that two of the most appealing and interesting characters so far are people of color. And this was just the pilot. The writing staff is multicultural (which is less common than you might think). But the most ironic aspect of this discussion is no one has mentioned that Jeff Bell was also the creator and executive producer of "Day Break" which is the only prime time action-adventure series I can think of that had a solo African American lead. As in, not a sidekick, not part of a team--the show's main character. So he's hardly someone avoiding heroic characters of color.

In addition, Mr. Bell and some of his writers spoke personally with the questioner after the panel and addressed his concerns to his satisfaction.

Seems to me this is a dead story. Move on. And next time, adding a little background on the main players might have been useful.
Wasn't an issue with the 1983/1984 version of the show
Posted by LizzieBirdForever on July 27th, 12:14pm
The panel at Comic-Con didn't approach this concern well at all. In the 1980's version of this show, Leonardo Cimino's character, playing a survivor of the Holocaust, compared the visitors to Nazi Germany. He introduced the meaning of the V for Victory. Also, both the visitors and the resistance were pretty ethnically diverse. The Taylor family (African Americans) were heroes/resistant fighters from the beginning.
Answer the Question
Posted by Rosie on July 27th, 12:06pm
Granted, it might be nonsense. But the members of the panel should have just answered the question and put the matter to rest, instead of getting some guards to hustle the person asking the question, away from the microphone.
agreed completely
Posted by pico on July 27th, 4:13am
It was a fair question, and an embarrassment that they didn't answer it. The pilot in general had a superficial relationship with current events, but even if the race issues were completely by accident, their inability to talk articulately about it says a lot more (and a lot worse) than the pilot itself.

I have no problem with shows and their creators coming from a different place on the political spectrum than I do - in fact one of the more interesting discussions at Comic-Con (albeit way too short) was hearing conservative Republican Bill Willingham discuss the relationship between his ideology and the creation of gay characters in his strips - but what grated about the V. pilot and panel was the superficiality of their relationship to the current events that they drop in the show to make it seem relevant. I understand where they're coming from: they want to justify the remake by making it seem important against the social and political climate it's appearing in, and fair enough I suppose. But I got the sense they didn't put much thought into it other than name-dropping a few big issues.

I dunno, I'm still sorting this out myself, and I understand that the pilot-as-shown isn't the finished product yet. But I found their dodging the question to be unsettling and unfortunate.
?
Posted by The Jive Jedi on July 27th, 1:54am
I Agree. i to saw the pilot and the q&a. the piloy was great. and the guy's question made no sense at all. I mean none.
Talk about missing the mark!
Posted by Jamil Washington on July 27th, 12:33am
I'm sorry, but the above theory is just trying to REACH for something that is not there.

1.) I saw the pilot and it is clearly not attempting to create the overtones you are suggesting. Saying that the "V" pilot has racial overtones portrays an obvious agenda on the part of the person making that statement. It is such a stretch that it pisses me off as an African-American.

You might as well add that the Lord of the Rings movies had racial overtones since there were no black people in that. Or that Star Wars had racial overtones because when Darth Vader was "bad" he had a black mans voice (James Earl Jones) but when he became "good" he was a kind and gentle old white man.

That's just dumb.

2.) The main guy who came up with this "re-imagining," Jace Hall is AFRICAN AMERICAN! Do you honestly think that he would miss such an obvious thing? No, he wouldn't. I also seriously doubt that he (or any African-American) would sit down and create a story that perpetuates racism in this country (either directly or indirectly.) I see nothing in his IMDB work record to indicate a predisposition there.

PLEASE STOP THE NONSENSE.

Clearly, anything can be made into anything if people want to be stupid enough to look for it. I'd think as a journalist you'd be discerning enough to judge whether or not some stupid question asked by an idiot at a comicon panel would warrant an entire article like this.

Please don't perpetuate the stupidity.

-Jamil
 

Post a Comment

Name:
E-mail:
Title:
Comments:
Security Code:
 
 
Remember me on this computer
Follow Cinema Spy
CinemaSpy on MySpace
CinemaSpy All content on this site copyright © 2007 ~ CinemaSpy Entertainment. All rights reserved.
All movie titles, photos, studio logos & other trademarks used herein are the property of their respective owners.
This site may contain rumors and speculation that should be read for entertainment purposes only.
Use of this site signifies the acceptance of our Privacy Policy.
CinemaSpy is hosted by Nexcess.net. Site built by Face3Media & maintained by SplitMango.